Although Doctor Who is meant to be science fiction, where therefore virtually anything can happen, there are some problems with items that are key to the plot. For example, should there be a Torchwood in the alternate universe but no Doctor or Rose, when it was the Doctor and Rose that were responsible for Torchwood existing? Also, the newly created Cybermen have technically never travelled through time, and therefore should have been left on Earth at the end. It looks to me like this episode has sneakily broken a few rules to get Rose out of the story quickly, without killing her.
Hello and welcome to Southanuk. And what a find you have made! This is a blog right from the mind of the most clever, funny and sophisticated man on the planet Joseph Southan
OK...a brief summary of the various things I am/do:
1. Computer Scientist
2. Musician (mainly piano, percussion and arranging).
3. I used to do kayaking and sailing and stuff, but got bored and cold.
4. The Cambridge University Ireland Society representative for Fitzwilliam College.
That clip is just silly.
thats the whole point
But it’s a pointless and hopelessly random ending (that would have taken about 5 seconds to make) to an already extremely flawed episode.
It was ok ’spose bit sad that rose is leaving
Although Doctor Who is meant to be science fiction, where therefore virtually anything can happen, there are some problems with items that are key to the plot. For example, should there be a Torchwood in the alternate universe but no Doctor or Rose, when it was the Doctor and Rose that were responsible for Torchwood existing? Also, the newly created Cybermen have technically never travelled through time, and therefore should have been left on Earth at the end. It looks to me like this episode has sneakily broken a few rules to get Rose out of the story quickly, without killing her.
Leave your response!
You must be logged in to post a comment.
Southanuk
What I'm Doing...
Polls
What do you think of the new theme
Total Voters: 9
Community
Already a member?
Login
Have an OpenID?
Login
Login using Facebook:
Calendar
Meta
Podcast Feeds
Blogroll
Authors:
Joseph Southan
Hey all its Joe and I am the Administrator or "Lord" of Southanuk. Feel free to register and to post comments.
Illustrator-United
Lauren
I'm an 18 year old philosophising, slightly nerdy, opinionated, guitar-playing, busybody artfag. That's all really?
Mark Hogan
OK...a brief summary of the various things I am/do: 1. Computer Scientist 2. Musician (mainly piano, percussion and arranging). 3. I used to do kayaking and sailing and stuff, but got bored and cold. 4. The Cambridge University Ireland Society representative for Fitzwilliam College.
TomRed
I can't be bothered.
truranp
Recent Posts
Most Commented
Tags
Barack blog Boris Johnson Cambridge chij Conservative Dark Dragon Gravatar hax ie8 internet explorer Ken Livingstone Labour Liberal Democrats London Magners Mayor Mayor Elections Mayor of London movement Obama openBVE Playstation posting Southanuk Spyro trains transparency uni Wii Woolworths